Error Analysis Overview
This worksheet focuses on common mistakes English learners make when choosing between the Simple Past and Present Perfect tenses. The exercises help identify and correct frequent errors in tense usage.
Key Difference: Simple Past vs. Present Perfect
Simple Past: Finished actions at a specific time in the past.
Example: "I visited Paris last year."
Present Perfect: Actions with connection to present, no specific time mentioned.
Example: "I have visited Paris." (No time specified)
Most Common Confusion Areas:
- Using present perfect with specific past time expressions
- Using past simple with "for/since" for continuing situations
- Confusing time expressions (ago vs. for, yesterday vs. recently)
- Incorrect past participle forms in present perfect
Common Error Patterns & Corrections
1. Incorrect Time Expressions Intermediate
Present perfect used with specific past time references
I have seen that movie last week.
Error: Present perfect ("have seen") with specific past time ("last week")
I saw that movie last week.
Correction: Simple past for finished actions with specific times
She has finished her homework two hours ago.
Error: "Ago" indicates finished time → requires simple past
She finished her homework two hours ago.
Correction: Simple past with "ago"
Error Analysis:
Time expressions that require simple past: yesterday, last week/month/year, in 2020, two days ago, when I was a child, at 5 o'clock.
These expressions indicate a finished, specific time in the past.
2. For/Since Confusion Intermediate
Past simple incorrectly used with "for" and "since"
| Common Mistake | Correct Version | Rule Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| I lived here for five years. | I have lived here for five years. | If you still live here now, use present perfect |
| She worked here since 2018. | She has worked here since 2018. | "Since" + point in time → present perfect |
| We were married for ten years. | We have been married for ten years. (still married) We were married for ten years. (not married now) | Context determines tense choice |
For vs. Since Rule:
For + period of time (for 3 years, for a long time) → Present perfect if continuing
Since + starting point (since 2010, since I was a child) → Always present perfect
3. Life Experiences Intermediate
Confusion with "ever/never" and life experiences
Key Rule: When talking about life experiences (without specific time), use present perfect.
Did you ever eat sushi?
Better: Have you ever eaten sushi?
"Ever" asks about life experience up to now
I never saw the Eiffel Tower.
Better: I have never seen the Eiffel Tower.
"Never" with present perfect for "in my life" meaning
Exception Note:
In American English, simple past is sometimes used with "ever/never" in informal speech: "Did you ever see that movie?" However, for formal writing and exams, present perfect is preferred.
4. Recent Past vs. Finished Past Advanced
Confusing recent actions with specific finished actions
Situation: It's 10 AM. Your friend arrives at work at 9 AM every day.
Did you arrive at work yet?
Have you arrived at work yet? (connection to present: Are you here now?)
Situation: Asking about someone's morning at 2 PM.
Have you had breakfast this morning? (at 2 PM, morning is finished)
Did you have breakfast this morning?
Decision Flowchart:
- Is there a specific finished time? → Simple past
- Is the time period still continuing (today, this week)? → Present perfect
- Is it a life experience with no time? → Present perfect
- Is there a present result? → Present perfect
5. Practice Quiz: Spot the Error Advanced
Identify and correct the tense errors in these sentences
1. I have bought a new car last month.
Correction: I bought a new car last month.
2. She lived in Berlin since 2020.
Correction: She has lived in Berlin since 2020.
3. Did you ever visit London?
Correction: Have you ever visited London?
4. They have finished the project yesterday.
Correction: They finished the project yesterday.
5. I am waiting for three hours.
Correction: I have been waiting for three hours. (Present perfect continuous)
Aucun commentaire:
Enregistrer un commentaire